Match ends, Newcastle United 1, Manchester United 1.
Manchester United manager Ralf Rangnick admitted he “did not like the performance at all” after seeing his error-strewn side salvage a point at struggling Newcastle.
Edinson Cavani came off the bench to score a second-half equaliser following an at times shambolically poor first half from the visitors, during which they conspired to partly gift Allan Saint-Maximin the opening goal.
For much of the game, an out-of-sorts Red Devils repeatedly relinquished possession, missed tackles and failed to offer a sustained threat to a disciplined and determined home defence.
Cavani’s goal ensured Rangnick did not suffer a first loss as interim boss, but the point does not help them hugely in their quest for a top-four spot.
They have games in hand on those above them, but are seven points behind fourth-placed Arsenal.
“Today we didn’t control the game apart from a few moments,” Rangnick told Sky Sports. “It’s all about energy, physicality and who wins the second balls. In all those areas we weren’t at our best.
“You have to be ready and able to win those direct duels and this was not that often the case. When we were in possession we had too many giveaways and even with the goal, that doesn’t make things easy.
“Today was not a question of body language, it was a question of body physicality. If you want to be competitive here you have to get physical and this was not the case in many parts of the game.
“Our biggest problem was the mistakes we made. Even when we scored the equaliser we were not really controlling the game and taking the right decisions.
“I didn’t like the performance at all.”
It was a cruel result on Newcastle, who defended superbly and counter-attacked with intensity to produce their finest display of the campaign.
Had Saint-Maximin followed up his superb first-half run and finish with cleaner contact on a shot from point-blank range soon after the break, or Jacob Murphy’s late effort found net instead of post, the home side would likely have the victory they deserved.
David de Gea must also take some credit courtesy of a number of superb saves, none better than the one-handed tip over to deny Miguel Almiron’s follow-up drive following the Murphy shot.
The point is scant reward for the Magpies and leaves them 19th on 11 points, two from safety but having played more games than all their rivals – and four more than Burnley in 18th.
To add to Newcastle’s sense of injustice they also lost influential forwards Saint-Maximin and Callum Wilson to injury during the game.
Newcastle played three times during Manchester United’s Covid-enforced 16-day sabbatical, losing each and conceding 11 goals in the process, albeit against some daunting opponents.
The doom-mongers will point to the continued poor results, the fact that the Magpies have now conceded a Premier League-record 80 league goals in this calendar year and the dropping of a league-high 19 points from winning positions this season as evidence of their fate.
But those with glasses still half full can now draw on a performance of grit and occasional guile that not only outstrips all others they have produced this season but belies their lowly spot in the table.
They did not defend like a side that has conceded 42 times this season, offering a disciplined structure that frustrated one of the most elite forward lines in the division, especially for the first hour.
In midfield they have the unlikely emergence of the box-to-box Joelinton, who won tackles, drove forward and played sensible, incisive passes all night.
Up top, Saint-Maximin and Wilson were a menace for the duration of their time on the pitch and will have every Newcastle fan crossing fingers that their injuries are not too serious.
Yes, it was another frustrating night for the division’s most high-profile strugglers, but also one from which they can draw much-needed optimism before a January transfer window in which they are sure to be busy.
“I can’t praise the players enough,” Newcastle boss Eddie Howe told BBC Sport. “It was an excellent performance. I’m really pleased. We deserved to win and you’re left with the horrible feeling of not getting what you deserve.
“We are capable of beating anybody. We proved that today. I thought we all performed today.
“That’s got the be the standard we’ve set ourselves. We can be a force to be reckoned with.”
Manchester United remain unbeaten under Rangnick, but this is one of few positives they can take from an evening full of defensive lapses, sloppy passes, weak shots and surly body language.
With their games at Brentford and at home to Brighton before Christmas both postponed by Covid cases that also saw the club’s training ground closed for a time, this was their first game in more than two weeks – but rustiness can only account for so much.
It was Rafael Varane’s hesitancy in the first half that allowed Sean Longstaff to nick the ball off him in a dangerous area to set up the opening goal, but the returning French centre-back was not alone with such calamitous play.
His partner Harry Maguire was, at times, like a bull in a china shop, ushering in panic wherever he wandered, with those further forward failing to provide that first line of defence Rangnick demands.
They improved in the second half, with Cavani the catalyst for earning a point, but his poacher’s finish was the one landed punch on an evening of tame jabs and ill-judged, wild haymakers.
They have games in hand to try and close the gap to the Champions League places, but Rangnick has much still to do if he is to narrow the gulf in attacking efficiency between themselves and those above them.
“We shouldn’t be looking for excuses,” Rangnick told BBC Sport. “We have to meet the demands in terms of speed, tempo, rhythm, transitions.
“We had chances to score but so did Newcastle. The good thing is we got the point after being 1-0 down but the performance has to get better.
“We still have steps to go. Today was not a step forward. We need to decrease the number of giveaways and unforced errors and those steps of development we need to take.
“We have to take it game by game. We have physical games coming up against Burnley and Wolves. Results are on track but we have to get better than what we showed today.”
Player of the match
with an average of 8.20
Squad number10Player nameSaint-Maximin
Squad number7Player nameJoelinton
Squad number9Player nameWilson
Squad number21Player nameFraser
Squad number8Player nameShelvey
Squad number23Player nameMurphy
Squad number36Player nameS Longstaff
Squad number24Player nameAlmirón
Squad number6Player nameLascelles
Squad number17Player nameKrafth
Squad number5Player nameSchär
Squad number1Player nameDúbravka
Squad number19Player nameManquillo
Squad number34Player nameGayle
Squad number1Player namede Gea
Squad number21Player nameCavani
Squad number25Player nameSancho
Squad number20Player nameDiogo Dalot
Squad number27Player nameAlex Telles
Squad number39Player nameMcTominay
Squad number31Player nameMatic
Squad number19Player nameVarane
Squad number7Player nameCristiano Ronaldo
Squad number18Player nameBruno Fernandes
Squad number10Player nameRashford
Squad number11Player nameGreenwood
Squad number17Player nameFred
Squad number5Player nameMaguire
Match ends, Newcastle United 1, Manchester United 1.
Second Half ends, Newcastle United 1, Manchester United 1.
Offside, Manchester United. Jadon Sancho tries a through ball, but Edinson Cavani is caught offside.
Javier Manquillo (Newcastle United) is shown the yellow card.
Attempt missed. Edinson Cavani (Manchester United) right footed shot from outside the box misses to the left. Assisted by Jadon Sancho.
Harry Maguire (Manchester United) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Foul by Dwight Gayle (Newcastle United).
Attempt blocked. Joelinton (Newcastle United) right footed shot from outside the box is blocked. Assisted by Jacob Murphy.
Corner, Newcastle United. Conceded by David de Gea.
Attempt saved. Miguel Almirón (Newcastle United) left footed shot from outside the box is saved in the top left corner.
Jacob Murphy (Newcastle United) hits the right post with a right footed shot from the left side of the box.
Attempt saved. Jonjo Shelvey (Newcastle United) right footed shot from outside the box is saved in the bottom left corner. Assisted by Dwight Gayle.
Substitution, Newcastle United. Dwight Gayle replaces Allan Saint-Maximin because of an injury.
Offside, Manchester United. Bruno Fernandes tries a through ball, but Jadon Sancho is caught offside.
Substitution, Manchester United. Nemanja Matic replaces Scott McTominay because of an injury.
Attempt blocked. Edinson Cavani (Manchester United) left footed shot from very close range is blocked. Assisted by Alex Telles with a cross.
Substitution, Newcastle United. Miguel Almirón replaces Ryan Fraser.
Attempt saved. Allan Saint-Maximin (Newcastle United) left footed shot from outside the box is saved in the bottom right corner. Assisted by Joelinton.
Goal! Newcastle United 1, Manchester United 1. Edinson Cavani (Manchester United) right footed shot from the centre of the box to the bottom right corner.
Attempt blocked. Edinson Cavani (Manchester United) right footed shot from the centre of the box is blocked. Assisted by Diogo Dalot with a cross.